Grossbart promised to bring Marx a piece of fish from the feast but he gives him a Chinese egg roll. Marx does not like the mood of intimacy that Grossbart forces on him on grounds of their shared faith but he considers the matter. But this is where Marx draws the line. Marx has scarcely had time to stow his gear before Grossbart is before him, insinuating himself, as a fellow Jew, and trying to get special consideration and privilege.
Grossbart and Fishbein do not pay much attention to the chaplain, only Halpern responds in prayer. The three attend the service and so does Marx. This story is full of complex irony. Grossbart comes to thank him and to introduce his fellow Jewish trainees Larry Fishbein, aged nineteen, and the timid Mickey Halpern, aged eighteen.
A while later Grossbart brings also Fishbein and Halpern and asks for passes also for them. Summary The story is set in late springafter the end of military operations in Europe.
Grossbart is to leave the camp anyway, on which Marx signs the pass after all. Grossbart accuses Marx of acting like a Messiah when he learns that he sent him to the Pacific. Marx does not want to fight and argue with him, so he tells him that they will go to the Pacific. He served in infantry in the European theatre of operations for two years.
A week later orders come. Marx refuses to grant Grossbart any special treatment. In this sense, Marx might be perceived as a Messiah, the saviour of his people, though he is just one of many Jewish soldiers participating in the war.
He complains about the cleaning of the barracks which takes place on Friday nights when Jews are supposed to be in the synagogue. He wants a pass which would allow him to join his aunt in St Louis for a dinner on the occasion of a Jewish feast.
The next night Grossbart comes to ask if Marx happens to know anything about their orders. The next day Marx issues a public announcement which explicitly reminds the trainees that they are allowed to attend the Jewish service.
The story also explores the concept of Messiah in the context of the war. Thus, he is a prime target for Grossbart.
Why does Grossbart fling it in his face, so to speak? Grossbart accuses him of being an anti-Semite. When they are alone, Grossbart admits that the letter was actually about Mickey who has problems with the food.
Barrett appeals to Grossbart, pointing out the example of Marx who did much more for the Jews by killing the Germans than Grossbart by throwing up a sausage. Unwillingly, he is trapped into being a "defender of the faith" by Grossbart. The reader is informed immediately of the first conflict taking place within Marx.
He continues to push Marx until the turning point when, after Marx allows Grossbart, Fishbein, and Halpern to go off base for a supposed seder, they return bringing Marx not matzo, as he had requested, but eggroll, something that is as non-kosher as food can get.
Marx must decide which he will be first: One more note about this story: Trainee Grossbart allegedly throws up each meal. Marx uses his influence and changes the orders so that Grossbart will go the Pacific with others.
Marx has himself persuaded how much it would mean for the boys and signs the passes for all the three. He turns the tables on Grossbart and gets the orders changed back. Grossbart calculates to evoke emotions in people and exploits both his religion and his fellow trainees to achieve his selfish aims.
The phrase "defender of the faith," according to Laurence Perrine, usually suggests a staunch religious champion, but insofar as Sgt.
He wants to attend shul to get out of work. Captain Barrett admires Marx as a hero who fought against the Nazis and defended the Jews.Defender of the Faith. By Philip Roth. Photograph by Michael Jacobs / Alamy. In May ofonly a few weeks after the fighting had ended in Europe, I was rotated back to the States, where I.
Philip Roth's point of view in The Defender of the Faith is not illustrated through Grossbart who is a vain, unscrupulous manipulator who takes advantage of labels that have no meaning for him in. In these regards, Defender Of The Faith, by Philip Roth, can be considered an influential short story.
Published init is one of six short stories contained in the book Goodbye Columbus, Roth¶s first major publication.5/5(1).
Notes: "Defender of the Faith" by Philip Roth [Teacher's lecture notes] There are actually two stories going on at the same time in "Defender of the Faith.". 7 Philip Roth’s “Defender of the Faith”: A Modern Midrash Gillian Steinberg Mention Philip Roth and Judaism to most average readers, and you will hear.
Roth, Philip. "Defender of the Faith". Analysis. The story interweaves two main themes, the Jewishness and the Second World War.
It focuses on the conflict between two strong characters, Marx and Grossbart, who are both Jews involved in the war but who assume contrasting approaches to their religious and military life.
Roth, Philip. (b.Download